| A Blue Hope | Complete Level 10 - A Blue Hope | Bronze |
| All the Rage | Complete Level 12 - All the Rage | Bronze |
| An Unearthly Likeness | Play as Batman (Zur-En-Arrh) | Bronze |
| Aw-Qward Situation | Complete Level 14 - Aw-Qward Situation | Bronze |
| Bane and Gain | Transform Bane into Bane (Venom-Powered) | Bronze |
| Bat's All, Folks | Witness the 100% LEGO Stud Fountain | Gold |
| Beings from the 5th Dimension | Set both Free Play characters as Bat-Mite and Mr. Mxyzptlk | Bronze |
| Big Trouble in Little Gotham | Complete Level 8 - Big Trouble in Little Gotham | Bronze |
| Breaking BATS! | Complete Level 2 - Breaking BATS! | Bronze |
| Breaking the Ice | Complete Level 15 - Breaking the Ice | Bronze |
| Doughnut Discoverer | Find and destroy a hidden doughnut on a hub planet Find and destroy a hidden doughnut on a hub planet | Bronze |
| Europe Against It | Complete Level 7 - Europe Against It | Bronze |
| Everyone Loves Bouncing | Jump on bouncy objects 50 times | Bronze |
| Glide on Time | Glide continuously for 10 seconds | Silver |
| Hard Traveling Heroes | Set both Free Play characters as Green Arrow and Green Lantern | Bronze |
| Hey Diddle Diddle | Find a gang of jumping cows on the Moon | Silver |
| Intruder alert! Intruder alert! | Play as The Riddler in the Batcave Trophy Room | Bronze |
| Jailhouse Nok | Complete Level 11 - Jailhouse Nok | Bronze |
| Loontern's Space Race | Complete any hub race as Green Loontern | Bronze |
| Mirror... MIRROR! | Create a custom character | Silver |
| Need for Greed | Complete Level 13 - Need for Greed | Bronze |
| New Queens of Crime | Set both Free Play characters as Poison Ivy and Harley Quinn | Bronze |
| Nok Nok! | Knock out your buddy on the planet Nok | Bronze |
| Now THAT'S impressive! | Find and destroy a hidden Riddler Trophy | Bronze |
| One Giant Leap for (Bat)Man-kind | Visit all of the HUB Lantern Planets | Gold |
| One Small Step for (Bat)Man... | Visit the Moon Base in the Hub | Bronze |
| Pursuers in the Sewers | Complete Level 1 - Pursuers in the Sewers | Bronze |
| Same Bat-time! Same Bat-channel! | Complete Bonus Level - Same Bat-time! Same Bat-channel! | Bronze |
| SHAZAM! | Transform from Billy Batson into Shazam! | Bronze |
| Space Station Infestation | Complete Level 4 - Space Station Infestation | Bronze |
| Space suits you, Sir! | Complete Level 3 - Space suits you, Sir! | Bronze |
| Super Buddies | Set both Free Play characters as Booster Gold and Blue Beetle | Bronze |
| Super Pets | Set both Free Play characters as Ace the Bat-Hound and Krypto | Bronze |
| The Big Grapple | Complete Level 5 - The Big Grapple | Bronze |
| The Bright Knight | Play as Adam West | Gold |
| The Green Room | Find the hidden celebrity party | Silver |
| The Lantern Menace | Complete Level 6 - The Lantern Menace | Bronze |
| The Power of Love | Complete Level 9 - Power of Love | Bronze |
| True Hero | Attain ''True Hero'' status in any level | Bronze |
| Under the Red Brick | Turn on all Red Brick Extras at the same time | Gold |
| World's Finest | Collect all of the Trophies | Platinum |
